Why Your Recognition Program Might Be Like Thanksgiving Dinner (And Why That's Not Always a Good Thing)

You know that moment at Thanksgiving when someone asks, "Should we try a new recipe this year?" and the entire table goes silent? That's the same energy most HR teams bring to employee recognition: We've always done it this way, so why change now?

But here's the thing about tradition, whether it's holiday dinners or workplace appreciation, it only works when it actually serves the people at the table.

The Myth of the Perfect Turkey (And the Perfect Recognition Program)

We chase perfection like it's a requirement. The turkey must be golden and magazine-worthy. The recognition program must have flawless rollout, universal participation, and zero complaints. Reality check? Most turkeys come out a little uneven. Most recognition programs launch imperfectly.

And you know what? That's completely fine.

According to Gallup research, employees who feel adequately recognized are 45% more engaged. Notice it doesn't say "perfectly recognized" or "recognized through an immaculate system." Just adequately. Your team doesn't need perfection, they need to feel seen.

Twenty years from now, nobody will remember if your recognition portal had the sleekest interface. They'll remember the manager who noticed their late nights by sending thema gift card to their actual favorite coffee shop because someone paid attention.

One Size Fits None

Here's what drives me slightly bananas about traditional recognition programs: they treat everyone like they want the same thing. It's like serving turkey to your vegetarian cousin every year and wondering why they're not thrilled.

Your remote employee might treasure a home office upgrade more than happy hour drinks. Your coffee-averse team member definitely doesn't need another Starbucks card.

Research shows 66% of employees prefer personalized rewards, yet only 10% report being asked about their recognition preferences. That's a massive gap between what people want and what they're getting.

Modern recognition means letting people choose rewards that fit their actual lives, whether that's gift cards to hundreds of retailers, prepaid Visa cards, or merchandise. When my family finally stopped forcing the same menu on everyone and started asking what people actually wanted, dinners got way more enjoyable. Funny how that works.

Gratitude Over Grandeur

The most meaningful moments at the holiday table never involve the menu. They happen when someone shares a genuine story, when laughter erupts over a shared memory, when people feel truly connected to each other.

The same applies at work. The most memorable recognition doesn't come from elaborate programs or expensive gifts. It comes from moments when someone's specific contribution is acknowledged in a way that matters to them.

Consider this: 79% of people who quit cite "lack of appreciation" as their primary reason. Not "lack of annual awards ceremony." Not "insufficient employee-of-the-month plaques." Just lack of feeling appreciated.

What if recognition was as simple as a manager taking five minutes to send a customized and personalized reward? Or a system that lets team members choose what matters most to them instead of receiving generic trophies? Or a platform that takes less than 5 minutes to set up instead of 6 weeks of IT integration?

Recognition works best when it shifts the focus from presentation to participation, from performing appreciation to creating genuine connection.

The Real Centerpiece

In the end, it was never really about the turkey, was it? And workplace recognition was never really about the plaque or the points system or the elaborate award ceremony.

It was about being seen.

It was about someone noticing the late nights you worked, the problem you quietly solved, the way you showed up when things got hard. It was about appreciation that feels personal, not performative.

The real recognition isn't complicated or expensive. It's choosing a system that makes appreciation easy rather than burdensome for managers. It's giving people rewards they'll actually use instead of another dust-collecting trophy. It's having the courage to honor what endures, genuine gratitude, while remaining open to what recognition can become when we free it from rigid tradition.

Just like the best Thanksgiving dinners aren't about following the recipe perfectly, the best recognition programs aren't about flawless execution. They're about showing up, paying attention, and making people feel like they matter.

Because at the end of the day, whether it's the holiday table or the workplace, what endures isn't the perfection of the presentation. It's the warmth of feeling genuinely appreciated.

Ready to rethink recognition? See how simple and flexible appreciation can be when you let people choose what actually matters to them.

---

---

Key Takeaways

• Perfection isn't the goal, genuine connection is

• One-size-fits-all recognition fails because people aren't one-size-fits-all

• 79% of people who quit cite lack of appreciation as the reason

• Employees recognized adequately (not perfectly) are 45% more engaged

• The best recognition lets people choose rewards that fit their real lives

What's your take? Does your recognition program feel like a tradition that serves everyone, or one that's overdue for evolution? We'd love to hear your thoughts.